GROWING
PAINS
Fiona Apple delves deeper into the dark heart of dysfunctional romance
Fiona
Apple's right: There's nothing inherently wrong when a song ends in a minor
key. That's one of the central metaphors in "Werewolf," one of ten
emotionally wrought, musically spare tracks on her new The Idler Wheel Is Wiser Than the Driver of the Screw and Whipping
Cords Will Serve You More Than Ropes Will Ever Do, only her fourth studio
album since debuting, in 1996, with the multi-platinum Grammy-winner Tidal, and her second with a title that
exceeds a dozen-and-a-half words.
Fiona
Apple, The Idler Wheel Is Wiser Than the
Driver of the Screw and Whipping Cords Will Serve You More Than Ropes Will Ever
Do (Epic)
|
That romance can be treacherous terrain —
that, as Neil Sedaka once put it, "Breaking Up Is Hard To Do" — has
been a central motif for Apple throughout her career as a singer/songwriter/pianist,
a run that has been marked by nearly as many long silences as expansive album
titles. It's as if, in order to summon the muse, Apple must first subject
herself to nearly toxic levels of personal trauma, romantic turmoil, and
self-flagellation. Not that there's anything wrong with that. It's just that if
one bad date's an anecdote, two's a coincidence, and three's a pattern, then
Apple appears to have turned questionable mating habits into something of an
obsession.
"Every single night's a fight/And
every single fight's alright," she sings through jaws clenched tight on
the opening track of The Idler Wheel,
against a brittle celeste melody reminiscent of toy piano. And she starts the
next cut, "Daredevil," by quietly admitting, "I don't feel anything
until I've smashed it up," before working up to the raw-throated, feverish
demand, "Gimme, gimme, gimme what you got in your mind, in the middle of
the night." Sure, it's candid, as Apple is wont to be. But it's not
exactly a recipe for a successful love life.
"Left Alone" and
"Regret" are two of the more telling track titles on The Idler Wheel, as is
"Jonathan," which just happens to be the first name of one of her
more recently departed semi-famous flames, the writer/comic provocateur
Jonathan Ames. (Before that, it was deadpan street magician David Blaine.)
Reading autobiography into songs is, more often than not, a dangerous game.
But, when Apple croons plaintively, "Jonathan, call again/Take me to Coney
Island/Take me on the train/Kiss me while I calculate/And calibrate/And
heaven's sake/Don't make me explain," it's hard to imagine she's doesn't
have Ames in mind, especially when she concludes with the open ended,
"You're like the captain of a sinking ship/But I like watching you
live."
There's more. "How can I ask anyone
to love me, when all I do is beg to be left alone," she implores on the
chorus of "Left Alone," stretching the last syllable of that final
word out until it's barely recognizable. And there's a tinctured touch of
targeted venom in Apple's whisper-to-a-stinging-scream delivery of the daggered
verse, "Now when you look at me/You're condemned to see/The monster your
mother made you to be/And there you got me/That's how you got free/You got rid
of me," in the fittingly rueful "Regret."
So, yeah, the songs do remain pretty much
the same in terms of subject matter for Apple on The Idler Wheel. (For better or worse, the rhyme, “I’m a tulip in a
cup/I stand no chance of growing up,” from “Valentine,” is a good example of
honest self-criticism.) But the settings for the wounded soul-baring on the new
disc represent a rather radical – and wise – departure from Apple’s previous
albums, which she recorded with the help of pop-savvy producer Jon Brion and a
full complement of seasoned studio pros. This time, she teamed up with
multi-instrumentalist Charley Drayton, a jazz-trained percussionist who, among
other credits, made the cut for Keith Richards’ solo band the X-Pensive Winos.
Working in tandem, they’ve stripped each song here down to its skeletal
essence, mirroring, in a sense, the unfiltered flow of naked emotion Apple
pours into each track.
PERSONAL NOTES: There's a tinctured touch of targeted venom in Apple's whisper-to-a-stinging-scream delivery. |
Apple’s still a Tori Amos acolyte at
heart, a dark, smoldering piano-playing chanteuse given to deeply personal
poetic flights of fancy. But it feels like she’s growing into an artist who’s
more uniquely herself. It also sounds like she’s taken some pointers from the
quirkier symmetries of anti-folk songstress Regina Spektor, given the odd
angles with which she approaches piano chordings, the jazzy trills and sly
slurs she incorporates into her vocal delivery, and the avant touches she
includes like the recording of what appears to be a factory machine that
creates the rhythmic foundation for “Jonathan.”
Drayton’s contributions are largely an
exercise in modest restraint, as Apple exorcizes her demons with demonstrative
stabs at her keyboard, flowing arpeggios, and, of course, plenty of minor
chords. He adds a soft pitter-pat beat and some vamping guitar to “Daredevil,”
drops a couple of frenzied drum solos into neurotic rush of “Left Alone,” and
lays some complicated polyrhythms under the oscillating chords of the
reservedly optimistic “Anything We Want.” But just as often, he steps out of
the picture and lets Apple go off on her own strangely compelling tangents,
coloring around the edges with ambient shadings.
If, at times, that makes for a
challenging listen, it also marks The
Idler Wheel as Apple’s most complete artistic statement to date. She’s
certainly stepped out on the ledge emotionally in the past; here she matches
that by taking some chances musically, particularly with her voice. Indeed, the
album ends with nothing but a multi-tracked Apple singing three intersecting
verses a cappella fashion in “Hot Knife.” I believe it may also be the only
track on the disc that doesn’t end in a minor key.